As someone that as only seen Phish 5 times after these two shows i feel that the original review was a little to personal, these two shows were the best Phish shows I have seen even with the divided sky mess-up, it adds to the Phish experience.

It also seems that some people that have seen a lot of Phish shows have become Phish snobs and tear apart really good jams just because it doesn't live up to their Phish standards. Phish is the best live performance at the moment and i doubt that will change anytime soon.